Rye Homes under $500,000

Rye Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Rye, Colorado—a hidden gem nestled in the stunning foothills of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. This charming town offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and small-town warmth, making it an ideal place for those seeking a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life. With its breathtaking landscapes, vibrant community, and rich history, Rye is a wonderful place to call home.

For those looking to invest in real estate, Rye presents an exciting opportunity with homes available under $500,000. This price range opens the door to a variety of charming properties, from cozy cabins to spacious family homes, each offering a unique character and the potential for your personal touch. Imagine waking up to panoramic mountain views, enjoying outdoor adventures right at your doorstep, and having the serene tranquility of nature as your backdrop.

Living in Rye means immersing yourself in a friendly community where neighbors become friends. The town hosts various local events and activities throughout the year, fostering a strong sense of belonging. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby hiking trails, fishing spots, and opportunities for camping, while families can enjoy the local parks and recreational areas.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a retiree looking for tranquility, or an investor seeking a promising property, Rye, Colorado, offers an array of homes under $500,000 that cater to diverse needs. Discover the beauty and charm of Rye today, and let this enchanting town be the backdrop for your new adventure!

Newest Rye Homes under $500,000

6037 Columbine St, Rye
$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 242536 MLS
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath updated farmhouse nestled on over half an acre in the peaceful mountain community of Rye. Surrounded by mature landscaping, this unique property offers plenty of space, character, and versatility with a large shop, a separate bunkhouse with tons of potential, and an outdoor kitchen and barbecue gazebo perfect for entertaining. Inside, thoughtful updates complement the timeless character of the original farmhouse. High ceilings, beautiful original woodwork, and a cozy wood stove create a warm and inviting atmosphere that is difficult to replicate in newer homes. The expansive country kitchen offers plenty of room for gathering and truly captures the charm of farmhouse living. A spacious living room provides easy access to the bedrooms and flows into a bright, welcoming sunroom. From there, step onto the covered front porch, relax, and enjoy the cool mountain air and peaceful surroundings. The home also features an enclosed porch, adding even more character and flexible space. With its combination of historic charm, useful outbuildings, outdoor entertaining areas, mature landscaping, and quiet mountain setting, this special property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the relaxed Rye lifestyle. Come experience this one-of-a-kind Rye retreat!

6037 Columbine St, Rye
8220 Maple Dr, Rye
$224,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 242236 MLS
Welcome to the serenity of the peaceful pine trees- yet only 30 minutes to Pueblo. 4 Bedrooms---2 full baths on over a half acre. Plenty of space for RV parking----hobby farm or horse property potential--- NO HOA----GREAT WELL with crystal clean mtn water----NEW ROOF--NEW WINDOWS---Refrigerated Air---Forced AIR natural gas Furnace-----Cozy pellet stove on a thermostat----too many features to name-----come see for yourself ----schedule a showing before this great deal is gone

8220 Maple Dr, Rye
8285 Park Rd, Rye
$355,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 242231 MLS
Calling all wildlife lovers and entrepreneurs alike! 8585 Park Rd is a very unique 3 bed/1 bath house with a cozy 1 bed/1 bath guest house behind. Lots of income potential! Could be a rental or Air Bnb! This expansive 0.63-acre paradise features a massive, wooded carport, complete with storage on the west side. The large, detached garage stretches into three large rooms, historically used for billiards/pool, a horticulture room, and office. Neat goldfish pond in the backyard between the main house and guest house. This place has space! The main house exhibits beautiful hardwood features in the living room, kitchen, and dining room, with built-in bookshelves. The primary bedroom has a gorgeous box bay window to showcase the surrounding forest. The third bedroom, on the lower level, can be used as a bedroom or office. Main house has a 400 gallon cistern in the basement, a fantastic option for water storage. Cistern, electronics and well were updated from 2023-2024. Don't forget the hot tub—it has recently been serviced and is ready to go! The greenhouse is enclosed and ready for this Spring's planting. The shed and RV parking have plum trees planted nearby, which produce delicious fruit to make jams and jellies. Make this mountain paradise your home today!

8285 Park Rd, Rye
10689 Charles Ln, Rye
$445,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 242204 MLS
Welcome to this 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering the space, upgrades, and functionality buyers are looking for, complete with a 3-car garage and workshop. The home has been extensively updated with a NEW oven, refrigerator, hot water heater, primary suite, carpet, retaining wall, and hardscaping. The exterior staining is only one year old, the furnace is approximately four years old, and the washer and dryer are approximately three years old. Additional improvements include updated windows and garage, while the large fireplace provides enough warmth to heat the entire home. Enjoy the peace and privacy of a dead-end road without sacrificing everyday convenience. Year-round road maintenance provides easier winter access, while high-speed internet and delivery services including Amazon and Instacart make mountain living more connected and convenient. The property is also equipped with a natural gas whole-house generator for added peace of mind and a cistern water system. With four bedrooms, a spacious garage, dedicated workshop space, extensive recent improvements, and convenient year-round access, this Rye property offers a great combination of Colorado mountain living and everyday practicality.

10689 Charles Ln, Rye
2070 Main St, Rye
$320,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 241953 MLS
Steeped in the early history of Rye and surrounded by towering Ponderosa pines, this beautifully restored mountain home offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Southern Colorado heritage. Originally built in the early 1900s by the Ashley family for one of their daughters, the home remains deeply connected to the roots of the town today. Rich with character and craftsmanship, this is far more than a home, it is a meaningful piece of Rye's story. Situated on a spacious one-third acre corner lot, the property blends timeless mountain charm with thoughtful modern updates. Much of the original hardwood flooring has been restored, preserving the warmth of the home's early craftsmanship, while original wood wainscoting throughout portions of the home was created using locally grown and milled lumber by the Ashley family, offering character rarely found today. Inside, bright natural light, warm wood finishes, and inviting living spaces create an atmosphere that feels both cozy and welcoming. The flexible floorplan offers room for entertaining, relaxing, working remotely, or hosting guests. The remodeled kitchen features updated appliances and workspace, while updated electrical and a high-efficiency furnace provide modern comfort and peace of mind. Upper-level bedrooms capture mountain atmosphere and views, while mature trees and the peaceful setting create a true Colorado retreat. Whether seeking a full-time residence, mountain investment opportunity this home is it.

2070 Main St, Rye
8172 Birch Dr, Rye
$475,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 241833 MLS
Tucked away in the pines of Rye, this well-cared-for 3-bedroom, 2-bath rancher sits on over half an acre and offers the kind of peace and privacy that's getting harder to find. Whether you're enjoying a quiet morning on the covered front porch or spending an evening on the back deck surrounded by trees, this property makes it easy to slow down and appreciate mountain living. Inside, you'll find vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, plenty of natural light, and a double-sided fireplace that adds warmth and character to the main living spaces. The layout is comfortable and functional, with spacious living areas, a well-appointed kitchen, and easy single-level living throughout. Outside, there's room for all your Colorado toys with a 3-car attached garage and RV parking. The mature pines, established landscaping, and multiple outdoor living spaces create a setting that feels private without being isolated. If you've been looking for a home that offers a little breathing room, a little extra privacy, and a true Southern Colorado mountain feel, this one is worth a look. Homes in Rye don't always come available in a setting like this, and it's easy to see why the current owners have loved calling it home.

8172 Birch Dr, Rye
8087 Oak Dr, Rye
$500,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 241788 MLS
Four Lots | One Good Life - Welcome to a property that gives you options-and room to dream bigger. Spread across approximately 1.62 acres and four adjoining lots, this 2,868-square-foot ranch is equal parts comfortable home, gathering place and country playground. Inside are 3 bedrooms and 3 baths, with everyday living-including laundry-on the main floor (because hauling baskets up and down stairs builds character, but nobody asked for that). The kitchen offers generous counterspace, abundant cabinetry, stainless appliances and an island ready for morning coffee, holiday baking and the people who gather wherever the food is. Oversized windows fill the spacious living room with natural light, while the stone fireplace brings warmth and a little mountain-home magic. Downstairs is where the fun lives: a wet bar, billiard and game space, fitness room, office and three-quarter bath. Outside, mature pines, mountain and valley views, fenced ground, a storage building and open-front shelter create room for animals, tools, gardens and projects. Add an attached 2-car garage, hot-water baseboard heat and a domestic well with a recorded 15 GPM yield estimate, and country living gets wonderfully practical. Come breathe deeper, spread out and stay awhile.

8087 Oak Dr, Rye
2469 Carlson Rd, Rye
$489,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 241591 MLS
Nestled on 35 scenic acres surrounded by rolling hills and breathtaking mountain views, this gorgeous ranch-style home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and versatility. The home features 4 bedrooms and 3.5 baths. It has a partially finished basement offering even more living space. The lower level includes a second kitchen, bathroom, and a spacious living area divided into multiple functional spaces--ideal for extended living, entertaining, hobbies, or a home office. Outside, you'll appreciate the partially fenced acreage, convenient circle driveway, and the peaceful setting where wildlife frequently wanders through the property. Start your mornings with coffee on the inviting deck and end your evenings under a blanket of stars. The HOA provides road maintenance and snow removal, making year-round access easy while you enjoy the serenity of country living.

2469 Carlson Rd, Rye
8229 Green Ln, Rye
$315,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 241524 MLS
Time to move to the country and leave the noise, polution, and population behind! Awesome completely usable 1.66 acres. Newly remodeled open ranch floor plan. New windows, new countertop, new flooring, new paint, and new deck.

8229 Green Ln, Rye
10594 Charles Ln, Rye
$203,500
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 240922 MLS
Charming, rustic cabin for sale in Rye, Colorado! 10594 Charles Ln in Rye is a 2 bed/1 bath mobile home that has been converted into a log cabin. This forest oasis with 0.445 acres has a newer well and historical cistern for your water needs. A large front deck greets you as you enter the home. The custom Aspen furniture inside can be included with the sale. Two spacious matching sheds are on the SW corner of the property, perfect for additional storage. Corner lot with easy access to roads. Call our office to set up your private showing today!

10594 Charles Ln, Rye
4920 W County Rd 650, Rye
$470,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 240410 MLS
The property is fenced with steel posts, four strands of barbed wire, and railroad-tie corners, with split-rail fencing at the entrance. The area around the Southwest-style stucco home is neatly trimmed and cared for, featuring native vegetation, rock-covered areas, and mowed trails throughout for easy walking. The home sits near a Gambel oak grove with a mowed picnic area. Enjoy outstanding views of Greenhorn Mountain, the Spanish Peaks, the plains, Fishers Peak near the New Mexico line, and even Pikes Peak to the north. The property has no restrictive covenants and no HOA or POA. County Road 650, also known as Lascar Road, is a well-maintained all-weather gravel road with no through traffic, ending at the National Forest boundary or ranch headquarters. The subdivision unit has 30 lots but only six homes, creating a peaceful setting. Located just 4 miles from I-25 Exit 64, 15 miles north of Walsenburg, and 23 miles south of Pueblo, this property offers privacy with excellent access. The land includes Gambel oak groves, scattered pion and cedar trees, and healthy native grasses. Wildlife includes mule deer, pronghorn antelope, occasional elk, coyotes, black bears, bobcats, and mountain lions. Properties on three sides have wells, though the current owner has hauled water. This beautiful custom home with heated floors in the master bedroom and master bath, scenic land, and prime location near National Forest Wilderness make the property a must-see.

4920 W County Rd 650, Rye
7937 Mount Baldy Dr, Rye
$415,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 239891 MLS
Check out this beautiful 5-bedroom, 4 bath, almost 3500 sq ft home with beautiful mountain views and large living spaces. The main level of this home has 3 bedrooms and a large kitchen and dining area, all with new flooring and paint, while the finished basement has 2 additional bedrooms and a large family room and bonus room. The property boasts 1.17 acres, a metal roof installed in 2021, a detached 2-car carport, a pergola patio, a playhouse, a loafing shed, and two more sheds for your storage needs. Yes, horses are allowed and wild animals to include deer, bear, turkeys, etc. frequent the property. Rye Colorado is located in the Greenhorn Valley where local amenities include banks, churches, schools, a pharmacy, a medical office, a grocery store, the HollyDot golf course, and a Library. Call me today to schedule a showing on this beautiful property.

7937 Mount Baldy Dr, Rye
Start Your Search